Leo Semashko. Peace from Harmony: Alternative to War in Iraq
Peace from Harmony: Alternative to War in Iraq
Dear Authors of "Peace from Harmony ", Friends!
War in Iraq, which is led four years, is that anything unlimited destructive extreme of modern humankind, which excludes its movement to social harmony, makes prelude for the world nuclear war and becomes the main reason for growth of other destructive extreme - terrorism. War in Iraq represents a fatal threat for humankind. War in Iraq, condemned by the Pope John Paul II (2003) and all peaceful forces on the planet, should be stopped. The global movement for social harmony in the world, which began on our site informational in February 2005 and political proclaimed by China in October 2006 should be opposed to war in Iraq and all other modern local wars as a sole saving and positive alternative. The global movement for social harmony in the world can not remain away from a key disharmony of modernity. Our mission proclaims: "NO FOR WAR! YES FOR SOCIAL HARMONY!". Therefore I like to announce our colleague Dr Charles Mercieca’s talk "The Crime of War in Iraq", which is held on March 16, 2007 in Ottawa (please, see in more details the leaflet in attachment). I invite all co-authors and friends of our site "Peace from Harmony" to support our comrade action and widely to inform on it.
For social harmony in the world!
Dr Leo Semashko
March 9, 2007.
The Crime of War in Iraq
Charles Mercieca, Ph.D.
International Association of Educators for World Peace
Dedicated to United Nations Goals of Peace Education,
Environmental Protection, Human Rights & Disarmament
Professor Emeritus, Alabama A&M University
What is the purpose of having rules and regulations when we can disregard them at will at any moment we like? Since the early days of human existence, those that transgressed rules and regulations to the detriment of others always tended to be punished, sooner or later. In order for us to understand the seriousness of such violations, we need to understand properly the significance of laws. In order to do that, we must have a clear concept of the four hierarchical laws of which ascetical writers spoke over the past several centuries.
Four Hierarchical Laws
St. Thomas Aquinas, who has been viewed as a genius by many, talks with great clarity on the four hierarchical laws consisting of (1) the divine law, (2) the natural law, (3) the ecclesiastical law, and (4) the civic law. They are viewed as hierarchical because in the event we do have a clash between them, then the one that is higher should be observed while the other that is lower should be disregarded. Before we illustrate this by examples, we need to form a clear concept of each of such laws. Afterwards, we may proceed to learn about their relationship as to enable us to create a harmonious world community. Let us put each one of them into proper focus:
1. The Divine Law, which is commonly known as the Divine Positive Law, consists of the Ten Commandments, which are found in virtually every religion by different names. In the Holy Scriptures we read that these were the laws that God gave to Moses. Hence, they are perennial in the sense that they are always applicable century after century till the end of time. Such laws supersede all other laws in the sense that they cannot be disregarded for any reason.
2. The Natural Law, which consists of the unique order that God set up in the entire universe from the first moment of creation. This is revealed in the law of gravity, where everything that is heavier than air tends to go down; in the law of plant life that makes the root of trees develop below the soil surface while the tree itself grows above the soil surface; and the law of conception that will inevitably result into the birth of the creature involved, in addition to other laws.
3. The Ecclesiastical Law, which consists in the enactment of rules and regulations made by spiritual leaders of any church or religion. Such enacted laws are expected to enable the adherents to observe better and more effectively the first two laws mentioned above. If, for one reason or another, laws are enacted that go contrary to the positive law and/or the natural law, then such laws ought to be disregarded by all means.
4. The Civic Law, which is man-made law that could change from time to time. No government, no political leader, no court, no authoritative source of any kind can enact and implement laws that go against any of the above three laws. That would include the ecclesiastical provided no laws are enacted that go against the first two laws that were mentioned. Hence, people are obligated to disregard any law enacted by any government that does not respect higher laws.
We are now in a position to make a value judgment about anything that goes on in our earthly community. For such a judgment to be valid it must be objective and not subjective. It is objective when we view a human action the way God sees it, that is, without any deception whatsoever. on the other hand, a judgment may be viewed as subjective if it is merely based on our interpretation or opinion, if it contradicts or goes against the other three laws in particular the first two. Let us now analyze carefully the Iraqi war.
Such a war cannot be judged as right or wrong by what politicians choose to tell us or by the rationale that is given by the weapons industry and the military industrial complex. Unfortunately, experience has demonstrated that many have become rich by turning the manufacture and sales of weapons, along with the promotion of struggles and wars, into a big lucrative business. In other words, such sources have developed the habit of making millions of dollars through the infliction of so much pain and suffering.
This may be viewed as blood money that is cursed. The American war against Iraq was waged in violation of the Geneva Convention, since Iraq was not a threat to the security of the United States. The reasons given for the invasion of Iraq, which included the having weapons of mass destruction, were proven to be entirely unfounded and false.
Besides, some of the leading statesmen of the world like Nelson Mandela and Desmond Tutu of South Africa, the Dalai Lama, Oscar Arias of Costa Rica and Pope John Paul II, in addition to others, warned the United States that such an invasion would be a grave mistake. The Pope even pointed out that such an invasion would create animosity between Christians and Moslems and that it would instigate more terrorism as to become totally out of control.
What did the war in Iraq achieve over the past four years? Before we prove the illegality and immorality of such a senseless war we need to enlist some of the eventual achievements of this abusive, cruel and disastrous war. Without a clear concept of these “achievements” we are not in a position to make a value judgment of such a war. This list is not structured in any specific order.
1. Destruction of the infrastructure of a nation: Thousands of houses and several hospitals, schools, and businesses were destroyed. People became homeless having lost all of their belongings. They could no longer have a place where they could preserve their food. Hunger and disease spread which led to the death of many.
2. Massacre of over 650,000 innocent Iraqis: In the process of conquering Iraq, supposedly to liberate it from terrorists, Americans killed mercilessly almost three quarters of a million innocent people consisting mostly of women, children the elderly and the sick. In addition, tens of thousands were maimed with legs or arms amputated.
3. Creation of tens of thousands of orphans: Many children had one or both of their parents killed. They will have to live now for the rest of their life with a trauma that will always be felt to be unbearable. As a result, these children have lost their real happiness and joy of life. Many are bound to spend the rest of their life in a state of depression as a consequence.
4. Increase in the number of deaths of children: Due to luck of food and medicine, the number of children dying in Iraq is literally frightening. According to UNICEF, 20% of Iraqi children are dying of starvation every year. What a nice legacy the United States has given to these Iraqi children! Tens of thousands of them have not gone to school since the American invasion in March 2003.
5. Making thousands of families to be homeless: Some US officials refer to the Iraqi war as the “war of liberation.” It is truly a war of liberation because Americans did succeed to liberate the Iraqis from their homes and now they are homeless; to liberate Iraqis from their markets and now they have nowhere to go to get food; to liberate Iraqis from their beloved ones and now they live in pain.
6. Maiming numerous civilians with arms or legs amputated: It is very sad to see now many Iraqis deformed for life. Many international reporters tell us that, in just four years under American domination, the Iraqis have suffered infinitely more than under the 30 years rule by Saddam Hussein, who was condemned to death just for being responsible for the death of 146 people.
7. Disruption in the education of children at all levels: A nation is as good and bad as its people in terms of education, culture, and religious practices. We are now setting up an Iraqi nation consisting of a generation that is being limited in its educational endeavors. This Iraqi war instilled in many the deprivation of a will to live, which explains the story of the so called suicide bombers.
8. Creating a great shortage of food: For about ten years prior to the Iraqi invasion, the United States put sanctions on Iraq that made it difficult for this nation to secure the vital needs of the people. Because of that every year 10% of the children died of starvation, as reported by UNICEF. Now, the food shortage has even increased and the country is suffering immensely.
9. Instigation of hatred and revenge against Americans: The Iraqi people, as a whole, attribute all the mess that is going on in Iraq to the presence of US troops. Teenagers were asked by humanitarian organizations what did they think was the source of all their problems. They all said: “The presence of Americans. We want them all to leave Iraq. We want them just leave us alone.”
10. Exploitation of Iraq’s natural resources: Some political analysts tell us that the United States, in invading Iraq, had ulterior motives, which consisted in the confiscation of oil. As a capitalist nation, the United States is run by big corporations, which control not only the economy of the entire nation but also the entire US government.
In other words, the United States is ruled by the Corporate Trinity of Evil, consisting of the weapons industry, the construction companies and the oil enterprises. They work hand in hand. The weapons industry destroys the infrastructure of a nation; then the construction companies go there to rebuild the nation while the oil enterprises step in to control the natural resources.
11. Imposition of a notorious, cruel and heartless dictatorship: The feeling among the vast majority of the people in Iraq is this. The Iraqis were much better before the American invasion than after. And they explain why. Before the American invasion, the Iraqis had their own homes. The spouses enjoyed each other and they loved seeing their children growing up.
Parents were happy to see their beloved children playing and enjoying themselves. Now, those that manage to be still alive are mourning deeply the loss of so many of their family members, relatives and friends. They feel sad and many do feel that they have nothing to live for now, that their life has been fully ruined. Many feel so upset and angry at the Americans who killed their beloved ones they feel their only goal in life is to kill as many Americans as they can.
Needless to say, every Iraqi that tries to avenge the death of his dear family members, relatives and friends is quickly labeled by the US government as Al-Qaeda, even though such Iraqis may dislike the Al-Qaeda in no lesser way than they dislike the American soldiers. The saintly Pope John Paul II had warned the United States that the invasion of Iraq would create great animosity and that it would turn the region into a ground of terrorism that would go out of control. We are witnessing today the execution of the Pope’s prophetic warning.
12. Destruction of the rich heritage of an old civilization: Iraq is not just another country. It is a unique country that could be viewed as a sacred ground for Jews, Christians and Moslems since most events related in the Bible took place there. In just four years, this needless and atrocious war has destroyed what has been built over a period of some three thousand years.
13. Endangering unnecessarily the lives of young Americans: Over 3,000 Americans were killed, not counting those that committed suicide. Besides, more than 23,000 were wounded with arms or legs amputated and quite a few with disfigured faces for life. These young Americans did not choose to go to war. If they had a choice, the vast majority would have opted for sure not to go.
Besides, because of this war, many young American soldiers had their marriage broken ending up in a divorce. once these young Americans are sent to fight, to destroy the infrastructure of a nation, and to kill “anything that moves,” as they are often told, their life, quite often, deteriorates psychologically. We need to keep in mind that, for all practical purposes, the life of American soldiers is sacred in no lesser way than that of the Iraqis. After all they are all children of the same God.
We need to bring to our attention here the words of former US President Dwight Eisenhower in his farewell speech to the US Congress. He said: “Remember that every dollar you spend on weapons and war is a theft from the hungry and the poor.” This World War II US General knew very well that every war is barbaric, that in a war everyone is a loser and no one a winner. He also warned about the weapons industrial complex that for profit the lethal product of this industry may go completely out of control. This would be a great catastrophe for it would hasten the road to Armageddon.
To this send, the time is ripe to start viewing as criminals all those who have turned the manufacture and the indiscriminate sales of weapons, along with the waging of wars into a lucrative business. Countless millions of dollars are being made through the infliction of merciless killing of tens of thousands of innocent people amounting to millions on a global scale.
What amazes every sensible person in the world lies in the fact that hardly any news media reporter ever tries to investigate the kind of money those government officials that promote wars might be making behind the curtain. People need an explanation of how most government officials initially have enough money to make ends meet and then, all of a sudden, they become millionaires. Scholars of political science have concluded that such excessive money made by politicians comes from weapons and wars.
War as Betrayal of People
If US President Dwight Eisenhower were alive today he would have probably referred to government officials who continue to pour billions of dollars on the manufacture of more and more weapons and the promotion of more and more wars as “traitors” who, like Judas Iscariot, are continuously betraying innocent people and sending them to their grave before they even know it. They are never going to reveal their real intent. on the contrary, they try to cover their intent very carefully by referring to anything negative and destructive they do through the usage such phraseology as “safeguard of American interests” and as “national defense and security.”
To get back to where we started, every crime that takes place in the world constitutes a violation of one or more laws, especially against the divine positive law and the natural law, since both of such laws are God-made laws. This means that they can never be modified or changed till the end of time. Among such laws we find that we should not kill anyone under no circumstance whatsoever, that we should not lie to people when we talk to them, that we should not destroy or confiscate the property of others, and that we should love others with respect same as ourselves. All of these laws fall within the divine positive law.
Besides, we are obligated to protect the environment from air and water pollution. Moreover, all people are entitled to free health care and education and to have adequate home facilities. All of these constitute a part of the natural law. If the billions of dollars that the US government has spent on the Iraqi war were spent on the needy, today millions of people sleeping in the streets like strayed animals would have had a home. All the hungry in the world would have had food and all the poor would have had available all kinds of medication.
Regardless of what we may hear to the contrary, the military by its very nature exists to promote violence revealed in the destruction of the infrastructure of cities and the merciless killing of countless innocent people that would include women, children, the elderly and the sick. We all know that violence breeds violence and more violence breeds more violence. This is thoroughly vindicated by the quagmire Iraq is in because of a war that should have never taken place.
The war on Iraq made me reflect not only on war but on Iraqi people and how they have suffered for years and how their voices have been silenced under Saddam Hussein.
For most people in America and Europe the first news they received about Iraq was about Saddam, the all edged weapons of mass destructions etc. however, no one heard of the thousands of Iraqis seeking asylum in other countries because they had been the victims of Saddam's regime, be it the Kurd, the Turkman or the Shiite population.Few knew that many women were raped by the sons of Saddam and then killed and thrown over the bridges of Baghdad nor about the thousands of casualties men and women disappearingthey were killed or put in jail.Those were the unheard victimsand what about the children who had to profess teir love to their leader who had absolute power of life and death over them. There were numerous murders and they are still going on.
Everyone seems to blame the United States, yes they invaded Iraq and toppled Saddam on false allegations but now the war is not against the US ot is against the people of Iraq, as there are more and more car bombs, suicide bombers and attacks against innocent Iraqi civilians those had been killed under Saddam are one again the target of a well organized militia. The aim is to creator fear and terror and to gain power of Iraq and make it once again a dictatorship with one leader being in complete control of society. one of the problems in Canada mostly in the academic world is that there is an anti-American policy that states the US is wrong and that is it, no one seems to care about the Iraqi civilians and offer a solution to the internal turmoil, if the US leaves now the people will be at the mercy of the militias and will once again be under a dictatorship.
I am not for the war in Iraq I am trying to find solutions to help Iraqis find freedom and to allow them to live in peace.One solution, would be for people of the world to unite and demand that the UN send in Peace Keepers. We could petition the UN to make suicide bombers acrime against humanity.We could think of solutions to make sure that all Iraqi civilians mostly the women and children are protected. They (women and children) are the most vulnerable and are the targets of those who use bombs to terrorize and to control.
If one listens to the stories of Iraqis prior to Saddam, under Saddam, one will know the people.For 40 years I had many Iraqi friends from all religious persuasions they areJewish.Jews came to Canada as they were persecuted and were left stateless after 1948 or 1950 they lost everything and I mean everything except their dignity and love for their homeland.No one cared or cares about them, no academic record is found,Under Saddam they immigrated to Canada for various reasons.Christians came as they were a minority and persecuted. Shiite came as had seen their family members being arrested and killed they feared for their lives. Kurds came as they were killed and gazed.Sunni came to find religious freedom in Canada as they were against a dictatorship that forbade them all to practice their religion in peace.... I have not yet found one academic book that speaks about all of these people.Someone told me many years ago that Saddam was a murderer and that Americans and Europeans should go and see what he was doing to the people of Iraq.The people of Iraq are suffering their stories have to be told they have a history and a long tradition of being warm and generous, hospitality is a core value and their food is great....
Prior to doing myI did my research for my master;s thesis on Jews from Egypt between 1947 and 1967, I tried to find information on the Jewish and Christian communities living in the area we call the Middle East, a British and American invention of the 19th century and early 20th century after the downfall of the Ottoman Empire... I found very few books and basically no interest on the part of most academics... I looked for information on Yemen, Iraq, Iran, Lebanon, I also looked at Morocco, Algeria prior to the war, etc.I looked at religion: Kurds, Druize, Christians Eastern tradition Catholics or Copt Christians, Alawi Muslims, Sunnis and Shiite, in those countries the only books written were about the Sufi and one German scholar interest Anne Marie Schimmel or some mention by Goethein Germany.
I searched newspapers, in Canada, silence, I tried to find things my only resources was the voice of people, so I chose the Jews from Egypt to start and to document their lives as their story showed their struggle and how Quebec and Canadian politics changed their lives... They were French speaking and could not go to school in French as they were not Catholic. The only references to the "Middle East" came as a result of war, when the US or Britain came into play and the play between communism, socialism and religionism.... Religionism is a new wordwhich means according tot he online dictionary"Excessive or affected religious zeal" in my mind it means, that we as Westerners define the other's religion by our standards and not theirs... We do not know the people yet we can tell them how to act and too often our points of views are biased as we only have one side of the story our side which has not been documented... one side information gives us a faulty conclusion... I do not have "the truth" as it evolves...
The Americans did not kill all of those people under Saddam or since 1947, their intentions might not be pure but they are not the problem nor are they the solution... I just wish that academics got to know the people and stop being anti-American or anti-Israel as the two are linked in Canada... This is why I personally believe with all my heart that we need to learn about history, listen to the story of people and try to find solutions that are personal, regional and global so we can live in peace, my solution is esay find the root cause of the problem listen to everyone and act with compassion by exposing the real problem and not causing another problem by adding to the chaos.
© Website author: Leo Semashko, 2005; © designed by Roman Snitko, 2005